If you build it - Traffic will consume the neighborhood, taxpayers will fund 73% of 2000 temporary construction jobs, Jeffery Loria will cash out in a few years, the Little Havana neighborhood will be revitalized disenfranchised, The Marlins will stay in Miami (for 35 years, guaranteed), etc…
This Friday, the Miami-Dade Commission will meet to determine the fate (maybe - they will likely postpone the vote) of the Marlins’ Ballpark at the Orange Bowl. As we noted earlier, from a strictly urban policy perspective – the current site plan (and funding scheme) is a calamity.
In addition to bilking taxpayers for 73% of stadium costs, we will also find ourselves footing the bills for at least $100 million dollars worth of parking. Then, in the not too distant future, we’ll realize we built the stadium too far away from existing transit, and we’ll need to fund a reasonable solution (like a streetcar west from downtown to the MIC) or our elected officials will think up of a $180 million scheme to create a people-mover extension from the Culmer station. By this point, I’m sure most rational people would then agree that it would have been better to save the hundreds of millions in parking and transit costs and just build the damned thing in downtown, near existing parking and transit to begin with… But hey, this is Miami, right? We can’t do anything right…
To reiterate – the current site plan will have deleterious effects on the surrounding community. In its current state, the site will act as a vacuum – sucking in traffic while providing few benefits to little Havana.
Central to the Marlins’ and public officials’ pitch to taxpayers was a promise that, in exchange for $450 million in public subsidies, the $609 million stadium project would propel redevelopment in the surrounding area, luring commerce, jobs, amenities and foot traffic to an area that sorely lacks them.
But the stadium site plan released this month suggests that the city of Miami’s approach might best be summed up as “build it and hope.”
Contrary to Andres Viglucci’s thoughts, to me, the current site plan evoke more of a “build it and to hell with the surroundings.”
In reading the article last weekend, I was curious if anyone caught onto the glaring contradiction posed by the political proponents of the stadium plan and the city planners.
On one hand, political proponents claim the park will serve as a catalyst, bringing commercial and retail activity to the community at least 80 days a year. This activity is confined to the “mixed-use” garages (FYI – parking/retail mix does not constitute mixed use) that provide scarce retail space along the base of the garages. This space, of course, is supposed to be sufficient to create a vibrant district around the stadium, regardless of the season.
Then the truth comes out we have the city planner’s take on the garages surrounding the stadium:
City planners say the size and shape of the garages were dictated largely by the Marlins’ need for 6,000 spaces and quick exit times.
My question remains, if we were planning a vibrant district around the stadium, wouldn’t we want to complicate the exit procedure so that people would linger around the stadium longer? It appears that is what the Seminole Hard Rock Casino did (rather well, I might add) in Hollywood (from what I’m told: just try leaving there in a timely manor on a Saturday night after a concert…) From a planning perspective, I would agree that this idea is convoluted, but it illustrates that the entire site plan is being designed so that drivers can come and leave as efficiently as possible on game day – not as it should be – a structure built to compliment a community.
As our own Tony Garcia aptly noted, ”Why are people going to come to this area? What’s going to make it a destination, and not just for baseball games?…You need a better mix of uses here, not just parking garages.”
Below are a few images of some other successful baseball parks around the country. These stadiums, particularly San Diego’s Petco Park, exemplify what a Baseball stadium should look like, how it should fit in with the surroundings, and how people interact with these spaces not just during baseball season, but 365 days a year. Compare these parks to the rendering above.
CategoriesAccident Airport bicycles bike lanes Bike Miami Days biking Biscayne Boulevard Brickell bus Climate Change Coconut Grove complete streets Congestion Density Downtown FDOT High Speed Rail MDT Metrorail Miami Miami-Dade County Miami-Dade Transit Miami 21 Miami Beach Museum Park News NIMBY Parking Parks Pedestrian Pedestrians Pic o' the Day Public Transit Rickenbacker Causeway Sprawl Streetcar Traffic Transit Transitography Transit Oriented Development Transportation Tri-Rail Uncategorized Urban Design Urban Planning
South Florida Transportation
- Emerge Miami
- Florida Bicycle Association
- Florida Department of Transportation
- Florida Greenbook Roadway Design Manual
- Green Mobility Network
- Miami Bike Report
- Miami-Dade BPAC
- Miami-Dade Expressway Authority
- Miami-Dade Transit
- Slow Bike Miami
- Spokes 'n' Folks
- State of Florida Bike/Ped Laws
- TACOLCY Bicycle Club
- The M-Path to Enlightenment
- The Miami Bike Scene
- Transit to MIA
- Tri-Rail (South Florida Regional Transportation Authority)
Transit Blogs and Resources
- City Transit Advocates
- Metro Library and Archive Transportation Headlines
- The Transport Politic
- Midwest High Speed Rail
- Design New Haven
- Portland Transport
- Welcome to the FastLane: The Official Blog of the U.S. Secretary
- Spacing Wire • understanding the urban landscape
- CTA Tattler
- Greater Greater Washington
- Human Transit
- Off the Kuff
- Buildings and Food
- Transit In Utah
- Trains For America
- The Overhead Wire
- JACKSONVILLE TRANSIT
- CoolTown Studios
- public transit
Planning and Design Resources
- immobilier on Great Live Music Coming to Downtown
- Matthew Toro on Metrorail ‘Bike and Ride’ Gets a Boost With New Hanging Bike Racks
- Anonymous on Metrorail ‘Bike and Ride’ Gets a Boost With New Hanging Bike Racks
- M on New Bicycle Lanes on South Miami Avenue
- M on Has Metrorail’s Train Tracker Affected Your Commute?
- Steve Meyer on Has Metrorail’s Train Tracker Affected Your Commute?
- Super-Healthy City Gets First McDonalds December 19, 2011Loma Linda, California has an average lifespan higher than most cities, and a significant population of vegetarians. Last week, the city council approved the first McDonald's in town. Will it have an impact on the community's health? read more […]
- The Metabolism of the Urban Web December 19, 2011Regular Planetizen contributors Nikos Salingaros and Michael Mehaffy get deep into the importance of network connectivity in cities and the reasons why sprawl is incredibly ineffective. read more […]
- Escaping the Data and Going With Your Gut December 19, 2011Jeff Wood, no stranger to transportation modeling and data-crunching, suggests its time to open up transit planning to gut-level reactions. read more […]
- Life in the Slow Lane December 19, 2011After decades of building for speed, cities are rediscovering the virtues of slow: walking, biking and streetcars are taking over from freeways. read more […]
- The Tea Party vs. Urban Planning December 19, 2011Anthony Flint reports on a number of planning initiatives stopped in their tracks by protesting Tea Party members, who are strongly opposed to "smart growth communism." read more […]
- Parking Garage to be Topped with Urban Farm December 19, 2011The City of Vancouver is building a 6,000 sq. ft. greenhouse atop a downtown parking garage as part of its goal to become the greenest city in the world by 2020. read more […]
- Cleveland's Growing Problem with Abandoned Homes December 19, 201160 Minutes reports on Cleveland, Ohio's growing problem of abandoned homes, where 1/5th of all houses are now vacant. read more […]
- Cities Unprepared to Help Those in Need December 19, 2011A new report says that U.S. cities are lacking in preparation (and in funds) for providing food and shelter for those in need. read more […]
- Businesses Drive Regionalism December 19, 2011Ian Scott attends a symposium sponsored by The Citistates Group on the topic of regionalism and comes away with a greater understanding of having an effect at the regional level. read more […]
- Stadium Seats Recycled Into Bus Stops December 18, 2011An "independent urbanist" group in Indianapolis spearheaded an idea to take seats from the closing Bush Stadium minor league ballpark to be used as much-needed bus stop furniture. read more […]
- Super-Healthy City Gets First McDonalds December 19, 2011
- Riders herald holiday season December 4, 2011Cyclists pause before setting off Saturday on Green Mobility Network's third annual Toy Ride with gifts for the Marines' Toys for Tots campaign. Before their stop for a taco lunch they breezed by some of the busy Art Deco Miami scene in Wynwood and Midtown. The day was perfect for riding. Lots of cyclists in the neighborhood showed the growing need […]
- Ride bikes, give toys December 2, 2011We'll welcome the season of giving with our annual Toy Ride on December 3. Please meet us at the Government Center Metrorail Station at 10:30 a.m. for this foray into Midtown and maybe Wynwood to deliver our kiddie delights to the Toys for Tots drive. There'll be lunch at Lime Fresh, too. If you're coming, please respond at our Facebook page. […]
- Come join our Leftovers Ride November 18, 2011On the Sunday after Thanksgiving, we'll ride into Miami's Wynwood neighborhood for a cupping (tasting) at Panther Coffee. Our meeting time on Nov. 27 is 1:30 p.m. at Metrorail's Vizcaya Station. First 30 cyclists to arrive there get a free ticket for the cupping. Lights and locks advised. It may be dark when you return. read more […]
- Riders herald holiday season December 4, 2011